Kalamazoo Historic District Commission Postpones Decision on Removed Roof Cresting

3 Min Read

The Kalamazoo Historic District Commission postponed a decision Tuesday, November 17, on metal roof cresting removed from a historic-district home at 712 Eleanor.

The owner replaced the roof with an overlay in late October. The roofer removed the home’s decorative metal cresting, and the owner had it discarded. The owner told the commission by phone that the cresting was heavily rusted and that he considered reinstalling it unsafe.

Work in the district requires review, and the roof work began without a permit. The city’s Historic Preservation Coordinator told the owner that removing the cresting had to come before the commission, and the owner applied.

How the commission handled it
When work has already been done, the commission reviews it as though it had not been. The coordinator said this gives every applicant the same footing.

  • A motion to approve a Certificate of Appropriateness failed, with all six members present voting no.
  • The commission then voted unanimously to rescind that vote.
  • It voted unanimously to postpone the decision to its Dec. 15 meeting.
  • The owner must provide the coordinator with research and ideas for replicating or reasonably approximating the removed cresting by noon Dec. 8.

A postponement keeps the case open. The coordinator explained that a denial would end it.

What commissioners weighed
The coordinator’s report found the cresting was not a character-defining feature of this home’s architectural style, and that removing it did not violate two Secretary of the Interior standards. The city’s local guidelines say removed cresting may be reinstalled if historical documentation shows it was there or if the full commission approves.

The earliest photograph staff found showing the cresting dates to 2006. A commissioner said he recalled it on the house in 1985. Commissioner James Johnson said he was concerned about Standard 6, which calls for repairing deteriorated historic features rather than replacing them. Other commissioners said they would like to see the cresting restored but were unsure whether its removal was a violation.

What property owners should know
Exterior work in Kalamazoo’s historic districts must be reviewed to make sure it meets historic preservation standards. Most of the time, work can be approved by the City’s Historic Preservation Coordinator. If damage requires emergency repairs, owners can secure the property without approval and should call the coordinator on the next business day. The coordinator’s office can be reached at (269) 337-8804.

What’s next
The commission will take the case up again at its December 15 meeting. The commission’s meetings are open to the public and broadcast on Public Media Network.

Share This Article