Oshtemo Township Planning Commission Reviews Zoning Rewrite, Overlay Districts and Planned Developments

5 Min Read

Oshtemo Township’s Planning Commission reviewed proposed zoning changes Nov. 19, including eliminating several overlay districts and raising density limits for planned developments.

The commission heard the latest installment of the township’s zoning ordinance update. No votes were taken on the proposed changes. Public Media Network recorded the full meeting; watch it below.

Corrected zoning map

Staff said the preliminary zoning map in the commission’s packet shows about a dozen parcels incorrectly because of split zoning and data issues. A corrected map will come back to the commission next month.

Flex space in neighborhood mixed-use areas

Commissioners discussed language in the neighborhood mixed-use district that would let vehicles pass through “flex space” in front of a building. Staff said the provision is an access feature. It lets a business with a pickup window use one driveway instead of two, which also means fewer breaks in the sidewalk.

Commissioners said they supported pickup service but were concerned about pedestrian safety, and about the ordinance appearing to encourage drive-throughs in residential mixed-use areas. Staff noted that the township’s waiver provision would still let the commission allow it where truly necessary. The commission appeared comfortable removing the language that encourages it.

Overlay districts

Staff recommended eliminating the Ninth Street and West Main overlay zones, both residential and commercial versions, along with the neighborhood commercial overlay. Their reasoning:

  • Residential overlays: The neighborhood residential district now allows townhouses and duplexes, which the overlays were created to permit.
  • Commercial overlays: The comprehensive plan’s place types give property owners a path to request rezoning, which the commission would evaluate against the plan. Staff said the commercial district now carries the standards of the old West Main overlay and allows higher-density housing.
  • Neighborhood commercial overlay: Staff said it isn’t applied anywhere on the current map.

The historic overlay stays, with a clarification. A 100-foot buffer applies around a historic feature, but the overlay itself doesn’t extend beyond the property boundary. Staff said the existing language conflicted on this point.

Staff also said the Stadium Drive area is the only neighborhood mixed-use area implemented so far. Other areas on the comprehensive plan’s place types map are possible future conversions.

Planned unit developments

Staff proposed several changes to planned unit developments (PUDs):

  • Density: The limit would rise from 8 units per acre to 15. Staff said 15 follows a planning rule of thumb for walkable neighborhoods, and that the township’s multifamily district tops out at about 14. A commissioner asked about matching the two, and staff said lowering to 14 is possible.
  • Site size: Staff said the minimum site size would drop from 20 acres to 10.
  • Phasing: Each phase would have to function on its own. If a phase doesn’t begin within 12 months, the commission may require the phasing plan to be resubmitted for review.
  • Public notice: Staff said the process would be clarified so the public hearing and neighbor notice happen at the concept stage, before a decision is close to final.
  • Minor changes: Small changes to an approved concept plan, such as parking layout, building size or stormwater design, could be handled by staff unless they refer them to the commission.
  • Open space options: Staff proposed removing the open space preservation article as redundant with the open space community option, which they said has rarely been used. Density for open space communities would be calculated from the district’s standards instead of a separate parallel plan. In neighborhood residential, for example, the minimum lot size without water or sewer is 22,000 square feet.

Public comment

One resident told the commission that large developments shouldn’t be able to change approved site plans without returning to the commission, citing flooding from past developments in Oshtemo. The resident also asked that the zoning ordinance match the master plan’s future land use map, and said the two don’t agree in places.

Staff said next month’s meeting will cover the revised zoning map, conditions for special land uses, and the site plan and special land use review processes.

Share This Article